I Support You! Just Don't Tell Anyone!

I Support You! Just Don't Tell Anyone! | RN-Mentor
Leadership & Moral Courage

I Support You! Just Don't Tell Anyone!

Private agreement costs a leader nothing. The people who speak in public are the ones who pay for it.

There is a particular kind of harm that occurs when leaders privately support what they are unwilling to publicly defend.

Over the years, I have had countless conversations with individuals in leadership positions who privately acknowledge problems within our profession, agree with concerns being raised, and even express appreciation for those willing to speak publicly about them. Yet, when those same concerns enter the public conversation, their support is nowhere to be found.

Encouragement That Stays Behind Closed Doors

What I have heard
  • “I agree with you, but I can't say that publicly.”
  • “You are saying what many of us are thinking.”
  • “Keep doing what you're doing.”

I have heard variations of these statements many times. While they may be intended as encouragement, I have increasingly come to question what they actually accomplish.

When leaders privately validate concerns but publicly remain silent, they leave those willing to speak exposed to professional retaliation, damaged relationships, and reputational consequences. They benefit from others' advocacy without assuming any professional risk themselves.

The Lesson Silence Teaches

More troubling is the message this sends throughout an organization or profession. It teaches people that speaking up is admirable only when someone else is doing it. It reinforces a culture in which maintaining relationships, protecting positions, and preserving institutional comfort take precedence over accountability.

I recognize that leadership requires diplomacy, discretion, and an understanding of organizational dynamics. Not every disagreement needs a public statement, and not every leader has the freedom to speak without consequence. But there is a difference between being strategic about when to speak and making silence and delayed responses of support a permanent leadership strategy.

The Values We Teach and the Values We Practice

In nursing, we frequently celebrate advocacy, moral courage, integrity, and speaking truth to power. We teach these principles to students, incorporate them into leadership competencies, and recognize them through professional awards. Yet, when practicing those very principles threatens institutional relationships or professional standing, the expectations seem to change.

I am becoming increasingly concerned that we have created a leadership culture in which private agreement is mistaken for professional courage.

Private support may provide personal reassurance, but it does little to change the conditions that made public advocacy necessary in the first place.

And perhaps the greatest harm is that those who repeatedly take the risk of speaking eventually begin to question whether the profession they are advocating for is willing to stand beside them.


Leadership is not simply about agreeing with the right things behind closed doors. At some point, our public actions must reflect the values we privately claim to hold.

Otherwise, we are not challenging the culture of silence. We are helping to sustain it through a futile attempt at diplomacy, political correctness, and the safety of silence.

Next
Next

Veterans' Health & Nursing